Skip to content

Product type

Protein pudding & porridge test 2026: the best protein pudding & porridge compared

Protein Pudding, Milchreis Style, and Porridge Put to the Test: Instant Desserts and Breakfasts with Added Protein from More Nutrition and ESN—We Tried Every Flavor.

8 products · 14 flavours tasted · Avg. rating 8.86

Leaderboard by Suppligator score

From our editorial taste test – every flavour rated individually (1–10). Updated: 7 November 2026

  1. Rank 1Protein Porridge NeutralMore Protein PorridgeSuppligator score 9.50 out of 10
  2. Rank 2Grießpudding neutralMore Protein GrießpuddingSuppligator score 9.25 out of 10
  3. Rank 3Milchreis Style neutralMore Protein Milchreis StyleSuppligator score 9.25 out of 10
  4. Rank 4Protein Pudding NeutralProtein PuddingSuppligator score 9.25 out of 10
  5. Rank 5Protein Porridge NeutralESN Protein PorridgeSuppligator score 9.25 out of 10
  6. Rank 6Apple CinnamonMore Protein PorridgeSuppligator score 9.00 out of 10
  7. Rank 7Cherry GingerbreadMore Protein PorridgeSuppligator score 9.00 out of 10
  8. Rank 8Chocolate BaseProtein PuddingSuppligator score 9.00 out of 10
  9. Rank 9Instant Maize PuddingESN Instant Maize PuddingSuppligator score 9.00 out of 10
  10. Rank 10ChocolateESN Protein PorridgeSuppligator score 8.75 out of 10

How we test

Every flavour is tasted individually and scored out of 10. The leaderboard ranks all rated flavours of this product type by Suppligator score. Our methodology explains the criteria and weighting.

All Protein pudding & porridge compared

Partner links (advertising) · The price stays the same for you.

What is protein pudding?

Protein pudding is an instant dessert containing protein: You mix the powder with water or milk, let it set briefly, and it’s ready to eat in just a few minutes. Unlike traditional pudding mix, you usually don’t have to cook anything; the ingredient list will tell you what a particular variety is sweetened with.

On this page, you'll find protein pudding as well as related products such as "Protein Milchreis Style," semolina pudding, rice pudding, and protein porridge. What they all have in common is that they can be enjoyed as a quick breakfast, snack, or dessert—warm or cold, depending on the variety.

Protein Pudding, "Milchreis Style," and Porridge at a Glance

In this category, you'll find instant pudding, "Milchreis Style," semolina pudding, rice pudding, and protein-enriched porridge. Most of them are mixed with water or milk—or poured over with boiling water—and are ready in just a few minutes.

  • Protein Pudding & Dessert: Just mix it up, let it sit for a moment, and it's ready—warm or cold.
  • Protein Milchreis Style & Semolina Pudding: Pour boiling water over the mixture, cover, and let it soak.
  • Protein Porridge: Cook with water or milk, pour hot water over it, or prepare it as overnight oats.

More Nutrition vs. ESN

Here’s an example: According to the product description, ESN’s Protein Porridge consists of milk protein concentrate and gluten-free whole-grain oats; it comes in Plain and Chocolate flavors and is prepared by mixing a 62-g packet with 200 ml of hot or cold water. More Protein Milchreis Style, on the other hand, is poured over with boiling water and left to soak, covered, for 10–15 minutes.

Conceptually, More Nutrition’s Milchreis Style and Porridge lines rely heavily on neutral base varieties (“Original Taste”), which, according to the manufacturer, you can flavor yourself using Chunky Flavour. ESN offers not only a neutral variety but also a pre-flavored chocolate variety for its porridge. If you like variety, neutral varieties plus flavor powders give you flexibility; if you prefer simplicity, go for the pre-flavored version.

The comparison list above shows which varieties are currently available. When shopping, you can save at More Nutrition using the ESN discount code or the code SUPPLIGATOR.

What should you look for when buying protein pudding?

  • Preparation: Mix with cold water, pour boiling water over it, or cook it? That determines whether the product is suitable for the office, on the go, or better suited for home use.
  • Consistency: Some varieties become pudding-like and firm, while others are more creamy and runny. The amount of liquid has a significant effect on this.
  • Flavor & Sweetness: Plain varieties are versatile, while flavored varieties save you a step.
  • Ingredients: Milk protein, rice, oats, konjac, or thickening agents—the ingredient list shows what the product is made of. Watch out for allergens such as milk and gluten.
  • Serving size: Individual sachets are convenient for on the go, while cans are usually less expensive per serving.

Preparation and Recipe Ideas

Neutral varieties can be flavored with flavoring powder, cinnamon, or fruit. The exact preparation instructions are on the package—for instant products containing konjac or dietary fiber, manufacturers often recommend drinking plenty of fluids.

  • Milchreis Style with Red Fruit Compote: Prepare the Milchreis Style, let it cool briefly, and top with berry compote.
  • Chocolate Porridge Bowl: Porridge with banana, nut butter, and a little cocoa.
  • Overnight Oats: Prepare the porridge the night before with milk or yogurt, and eat it with fruit in the morning.
  • Layered pudding dessert: Layer protein pudding in a glass, alternating with yogurt and crumbled cookies.
  • Semolina pudding with cinnamon: served warm with applesauce and cinnamon.

You can find more ideas for baking with protein in the protein baking mixes section.

Common Mistakes

  • Not enough soaking time: "Milchreis Style" and porridge need a few minutes; otherwise, the texture will remain grainy.
  • Too much liquid: The pudding will turn out runny—it's better to start with a small amount and add more later.
  • Do not cover: When boiling water, a lid traps the heat.
  • Stirring in the flavoring powder too early: For hot dishes, add the flavoring only at the very end.

Protein Pudding in Everyday Life: When and How?

Many people eat protein pudding or "Protein Milchreis Style" for dessert after dinner, for breakfast at the office, or as an afternoon snack. Since most varieties only require water, they’re easy to take to the office or on trips—all you need is a kettle.

It’s convenient to prepare food in advance: Make porridge as “overnight oats” in jars, let “Milchreis Style” cool in individual portions, and store them in the refrigerator. How long prepared portions last depends on the ingredients—if in doubt, it’s better to prepare them fresh.

If you want to try several varieties, it’s best to start with a neutral base and two or three different flavors to mix things up. That way, you can figure out whether you prefer the creamy, pudding-like consistency or the grainier, rice pudding- or porridge-style texture.

Here's How We Test Protein Pudding

We prepare each variety exactly according to the manufacturer’s instructions—using the specified liquid, temperature, and soaking time. We also taste neutral varieties on their own to assess their basic flavor. We rate flavor, sweetness, consistency, ease of mixing, and aftertaste on a scale of 1 to 10.

The ratings for each variety are included in the leaderboard above. You can find details on the process in our testing methodology.

Frequently asked questions

Which protein pudding tastes the best?

That depends on whether you prefer chocolate, vanilla, or neutral flavors that you can flavor yourself. The list above shows the highest-rated varieties from our tasting.

Can you eat protein porridge cold?

Yes, many varieties are also great for overnight oats—just mix them with milk or yogurt the night before.

How do you make "Protein Milchreis Style"?

Usually, boiling water is poured over the powder, stirred, and then left to soak, covered, for a few minutes. The exact amount of water and soaking time are listed on the package.

Can you mix protein pudding with water?

For many varieties, yes—it becomes lighter with water and creamier with milk. Stick to the amount of liquid listed on the package to get the right consistency.

Can you eat protein pudding warm?

That depends on the variety. "Milchreis Style," semolina pudding, and porridge are often eaten warm, while pudding desserts are usually eaten cold. The manufacturer's instructions indicate the recommended preparation method.

How can I add flavor to plain "Protein Milchreis Style" or porridge?

The easiest way is to use flavoring powder, cinnamon, cocoa, fruit, or nut butter. It's best to stir in the flavoring powder only after the mixture has soaked.

What is the difference between protein porridge and regular porridge?

Protein porridge also contains milk protein or another type of protein and is usually sweetened with sweeteners. The exact nutritional values are listed on the label—compare them with your usual oatmeal.

More product types

Further reading